Should I focus on digital or local businesses for my web design services, and how should I test which works better?
You don’t have to choose just one—you can do both digital and local. Run a side‑by‑side experiment for about two weeks: target local businesses across the US and South Africa in one test, and digital businesses in the same regions in another. Measure how many people say yes in each, how difficult it is to scrape leads (using time as a metric), and what average order value you can pitch for digital versus physical offers. Let the data tell you which works better.
No, as a beginner you should not target local businesses first. There’s a big list of things to target before going local—always start with digital, and consider hybrid or high‑cost‑of‑living countries before local. Local businesses are much harder to scrape leads for; you usually need to pull data via Google Maps API or address‑based scraping, which is hyper‑limited and raises the bar significantly. You’d have to invest far more money than for digital businesses, yet the pay is low, so the return isn’t worth it. Generally, these businesses have a high barrier to entry and offer little pay. If you want context, I’ll link a video about niches; three automation‑agency niches come with criteria I use, one of which is that they tend to be digital. For newcomers, that means definitely not targeting local businesses—it’s just a lot easier to pull the digital lever. If you’re experienced and see a genuine market opportunity with a particular type of local business, then I might consider it.
It's a common problem for beginners to spend too much time thinking about the business model instead of actually doing it. You're likely stuck in your head wondering what niche to pick, how to reach people, and which platforms to use. Rather than overthinking, you should test an idea in the market. Pick three things: choose an outreach minimum per day on platforms you have experience with—like DMs on Instagram, X, LinkedIn, communities, Reddit—and run it for a month without changing anything. After 30 days, if you do about 10 pieces of outreach per platform, you'll have contacted nearly 1,000 people, giving you real data to inform your next step. For example, you might find that your web development offer converts at 2.9% while your cyber offer doesn't perform as well, letting you focus on what works. This approach turns you into a scientist of your own life, gradually carving out the solution space and increasing your chances of success.
Focus on niches that have money and are digital—think B2B SaaS, PR agencies, or any service that can be delivered online. Avoid low‑ticket, brick‑and‑mortar niches like dog walking because lead sourcing is hard and expensive. To test, scrape lead lists (e.g., 2,000 contacts per niche across three or four niches) using a service like Leads Rapidly; that costs about $5 per thousand leads, so roughly $30 for 6,000 leads. You’ll also need about 12‑13 mailboxes at around $3.50 each, adding another $40‑$50, for a first‑month total of around $100‑$110. Send your cold emails, then compare which niches give the highest response rates, deepest funnel progress, and most revenue. Also look for mid‑ to high‑ticket offers, as they’re more likely to need automation.